{"id":2638,"date":"2024-09-08T09:30:00","date_gmt":"2024-09-08T13:30:00","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/?p=2638"},"modified":"2024-09-09T13:26:52","modified_gmt":"2024-09-09T17:26:52","slug":"flipping-the-narrative","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/2024\/09\/08\/flipping-the-narrative\/","title":{"rendered":"Flipping the Narrative"},"content":{"rendered":"\n<p>Year B<br>&nbsp;Isaiah 35:4-7a<br>&nbsp;Psalm 146<br>&nbsp;James 2:1-10, 14-17<br>&nbsp;Mark 7:24-37<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>May the words of my mouth O God\u2026&nbsp; speak your truth\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>I&#8217;m about to retire\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; I&#8217;m about to make a transition\u2026&nbsp; cross a divide\u2026&nbsp; of sorts\u2026&nbsp; from one way of spending my time\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; to another\u2026&nbsp; from one way of being a priest\u2026&nbsp; to another\u2026&nbsp; from one pattern of activity\u2026&nbsp; to another\u2026&nbsp; and in spite of everything I&#8217;ve done to prepare\u2026&nbsp; there will be surprises\u2026&nbsp; there will be things I didn&#8217;t think of\u2026&nbsp; or anticipate\u2026&nbsp; there will be situations which catch me off guard\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; from what&#8217;s been said about retirement\u2026&nbsp; from what&#8217;s been written about it\u2026&nbsp; to what it is\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and yes\u2026&nbsp; there&#8217;s a book called\u2026&nbsp; Retirement Planning for Dummies\u2026&nbsp; it&#8217;s the second edition\u2026&nbsp; so it must be complete\u2026&nbsp; it must have all the answers\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; to all the questions I might have asked\u2026&nbsp; if only I&#8217;d thought to buy it a couple months ago\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; it must be so complete\u2026&nbsp; that those of you who have already retired\u2026&nbsp; will wish you had had it when you were getting ready to retire\u2026&nbsp;<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>And so one other thing\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; I realize I&#8217;m about to do\u2026&nbsp; is flip the narrative\u2026&nbsp; from what culture says retirement is all about\u2026&nbsp; or what people say it should be all about\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; to what it actually is all about\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; from what I believed it would all be about\u2026&nbsp; to what it&#8217;s really all about\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and whatever that will be\u2026&nbsp; it will not only change what I do on the outside\u2026&nbsp; but will change how I am on the inside\u2026&nbsp; in how I think\u2026&nbsp; and how I feel\u2026&nbsp; in how my Spirit speaks to me\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; and in how I perceive and discern\u2026 &nbsp;]&nbsp; the narrative I&#8217;ve accepted will flip\u2026&nbsp; from hearsay to testimony\u2026&nbsp; from conjecture to reality\u2026&nbsp; and almost like when you&#8217;ve had your cataracts removed\u2026&nbsp; from blurriness to clarity\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>And as I go through this transition\u2026&nbsp; I need to remain vigilant\u2026&nbsp; I need to remain open to what I can still&nbsp; learn\u2026&nbsp; to how I can still be formed\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; to what I can give to\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; and do for others\u2026&nbsp; because if I think I&#8217;m too busy getting ready to not be too busy at all\u2026&nbsp; I may miss out on opportunities that may come my way\u2026&nbsp; on something that will flip another narrative I&#8217;ve been telling myself\u2026&nbsp; and which also turns out to not be true\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>Professor Raj Nadella writes\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; a few years ago\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; I saw a cartoon\u2026&nbsp; in it\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; there&#8217;s a CEO\u2026&nbsp; a laborer\u2026&nbsp; and a foreigner\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; sitting at a table\u2026&nbsp; the CEO has a huge plate-full of cookies in front of him\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; the laborer has one cookie\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; and the immigrant has none\u2026&nbsp; and the CEO turns to the laborer and says\u2026&nbsp; <em>Careful mate\u2026&nbsp; that foreigner wants your cookie!<\/em>\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; it\u2019s a clear attempt to shift attention away from the CEO\u2019s hoarding\u2026&nbsp; and to create division\u2026&nbsp; and Empire continues to do that even now\u2026&nbsp; by asking questions like\u2026&nbsp; <em>Who&#8217;s a real American\u2026&nbsp; and who deserves its benefits<\/em>\u2026&nbsp; and it creates additional division by pitting marginalized communities against each other\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; so it&#8217;s that much harder to address this oppression\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>The first-century historian Josephus\u2026 &nbsp;describes the ongoing tension between Jews and the residents of Tyre\u2026&nbsp; these two colonized communities fought over several issues\u2026&nbsp; but primarily\u2026&nbsp; over the limited resources that were left\u2026&nbsp; after the Roman Empire siphoned off what it wanted\u2026&nbsp; and Rome deflected attention away from its selfish economic practices by convincing these oppressed communities\u2026 &nbsp;that they could survive\u2026&nbsp; only by eliminating the competition from the other oppressed groups\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; with whom they lived\u2026&nbsp; and this led to a mindset of scarcity among these communities\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>The Syrophoenician woman\u2026&nbsp; &nbsp;and the deaf man\u2026 &nbsp;were both people on the fringes\u2026&nbsp; like the foreigner at the table whose plate was empty\u2026&nbsp; but the woman spoke up\u2026&nbsp; out of desperation for her daughter\u2026&nbsp; and those who brought the deaf man to Jesus\u2026&nbsp; spoke up on his behalf\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and there&#8217;s no record of any dialogue between Jesus and these advocates\u2026&nbsp; he simply takes the deaf man aside and heals him\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>But today&#8217;s Gospel records the back and forth between Jesus and this woman\u2026&nbsp; and I wonder what we can learn from Jesus\u2019 reluctance to grant the Syrophoenician woman\u2019s request for a miracle\u2026&nbsp; was it fear that if the food\u2026&nbsp; in other words\u2026&nbsp; the benefits of this new Kingdom\u2026&nbsp; were to be extended to her community\u2026&nbsp; that the Jewish people would have less\u2026&nbsp; would lose out\u2026&nbsp; that it would be a zero-sum game\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; in which only one\u2026&nbsp; or the other can benefit\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; but not both\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>And at first\u2026&nbsp; this is just how Jesus reacts\u2026&nbsp; and it may possibly have been\u2026&nbsp; at least partly\u2026&nbsp; that he was simply exhausted\u2026&nbsp; that his inner resources were depleted because of the miracles and healings he&#8217;d been performing\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; after all&#8230;&nbsp; the text says\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; that he didn&#8217;t want anyone to know he was there\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; but he spoke harshly to this woman\u2026&nbsp; saying\u2026&nbsp; it&#8217;s not fair to take the children\u2019s food and throw it to the dogs\u2026&nbsp; as though the Kingdom could somehow be depleted\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>Now The Jesus Seminar folk\u2026&nbsp; were a group of biblical scholars whose goal was to establish the authenticity of what Jesus actually said and did\u2026&nbsp; and they believe that Jesus must really have said this\u2026&nbsp; because it was kind of unflattering\u2026&nbsp; and it would have been so easy to leave it out of the bible\u2026&nbsp; but if it really could be attributed to him\u2026&nbsp; well\u2026&nbsp; you wouldn&#8217;t want to lose any of his actual words\u2026&nbsp; would you\u2026&nbsp; so we&#8217;d better leave it in\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and maybe\u2026&nbsp; <em>taking the children<\/em><em>\u2019<\/em><em>s food and throwing it to the dogs<\/em>\u2026&nbsp; maybe that was an expression that people knew\u2026&nbsp; which referred to someone who couldn&#8217;t appreciate what was being offered to them\u2026&nbsp; that it would be wasted on them\u2026&nbsp; kind of like casting pearls before swine\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>But the woman\u2019s insightful response affirms\u2026&nbsp; &nbsp;that even if her community gained access to the gifts of the kingdom\u2026&nbsp; Jesus&#8217; community would not be deprived of theirs\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and remember\u2026&nbsp; in the two stories which bookend this one\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; of the feeding of the 5,000 and of the 4,000\u2026&nbsp; Jesus himself flips the narrative by challenging popular notions of scarcity\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; so what this woman invites Jesus to do\u2026&nbsp; is challenge his own narrative about who&#8217;s in and who&#8217;s out\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; what she is able to accomplish\u2026&nbsp; is get him to question who he believes can be included\u2026&nbsp; and who can be healed\u2026&nbsp; and whether belonging to any particular group\u2026&nbsp; or tribe\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; disqualifies you\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and Jesus flips his own narrative\u2026&nbsp; and says no\u2026&nbsp;<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>Now we all belong to different tribes\u2026&nbsp; we all belong to different groups\u2026&nbsp; some of them are of our choosing\u2026&nbsp; like those who have similar faith journeys\u2026&nbsp; or the hobbies we share\u2026&nbsp; like exercise groups\u2026&nbsp; or gardening clubs\u2026&nbsp; or amateur astronomers\u2026&nbsp; or various kinds of support groups\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; but other tribes are not of our choosing\u2026&nbsp; like where our ancestors came from\u2026&nbsp; and the genotypes we&#8217;ve inherited\u2026 our inclination to develop certain kinds of diseases\u2026&nbsp; like Parkinson&#8217;s\u2026&nbsp; but our participation in any of these &#8220;so called&#8221; tribes\u2026&nbsp; ought not be divisive\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>But empire knows how to create division\u2026&nbsp; because the best way to bring folks together\u2026&nbsp; is to give them a good enemy\u2026&nbsp; and promoting this kind of mindset\u2026&nbsp; only increases the difficulty we have in working together to solve our common problems\u2026 and it is an affront to the values that Jesus espoused\u2026<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p>And if we&#8217;re courageous enough\u2026&nbsp; we&#8217;ll be able to acknowledge that we all have some unclean spirits within us\u2026&nbsp; we are all deaf to some things we don&#8217;t want to hear\u2026&nbsp; many of us can&#8217;t speak when there&#8217;s something that really needs to be said\u2026&nbsp; and we need to recognize that we all need to be healed\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; there are many narratives that we need to flip\u2026&nbsp; and if\u2026&nbsp; in today&#8217;s Gospel\u2026&nbsp; Jesus is having a hard time getting it\u2026&nbsp; it&#8217;s no wonder that we sometimes do too\u2026&nbsp; but while we may be daunted by the enormity of the worlds grief\u2026&nbsp; and while we may not be obligated to complete the work we are called to do\u2026&nbsp; we must remember\u2026&nbsp; that neither are we free to abandon it\u2026<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Year B&nbsp;Isaiah 35:4-7a&nbsp;Psalm 146&nbsp;James 2:1-10, 14-17&nbsp;Mark 7:24-37 May the words of my mouth O God\u2026&nbsp; speak your truth\u2026 I&#8217;m about to retire\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; I&#8217;m about to make a transition\u2026&nbsp; cross a divide\u2026&nbsp; of sorts\u2026&nbsp; from one way of spending my time\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; to another\u2026&nbsp; from one way of being a priest\u2026&nbsp; to another\u2026&nbsp; from one pattern of activity\u2026&nbsp; to another\u2026&nbsp; and in spite of everything I&#8217;ve done to prepare\u2026&nbsp; there will be surprises\u2026&nbsp; there will be things I didn&#8217;t think of\u2026&nbsp; or anticipate\u2026&nbsp; there will be situations which catch me off guard\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; from what&#8217;s been said about retirement\u2026&nbsp; from what&#8217;s been written about it\u2026&nbsp; to what it is\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and yes\u2026&nbsp; there&#8217;s a book called\u2026&nbsp; Retirement Planning for Dummies\u2026&nbsp; it&#8217;s the second edition\u2026&nbsp; so it must be complete\u2026&nbsp; it must have all the answers\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; to all the questions I might have asked\u2026&nbsp; if only I&#8217;d thought to buy it a couple months ago\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; it must be so complete\u2026&nbsp; that those of you who have already retired\u2026&nbsp; will wish you had had it when you were getting ready to retire\u2026&nbsp; And so one other thing\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; I realize I&#8217;m about to do\u2026&nbsp; is flip the narrative\u2026&nbsp; from what culture says retirement is all about\u2026&nbsp; or what people say it should be all about\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; to what it actually is all about\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; from what I believed it would all be about\u2026&nbsp; to what it&#8217;s really all about\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and whatever that will be\u2026&nbsp; it will not only change what I do on the outside\u2026&nbsp; but will change how I am on the inside\u2026&nbsp; in how I think\u2026&nbsp; and how I feel\u2026&nbsp; in how my Spirit speaks to me\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; and in how I perceive and discern\u2026 &nbsp;]&nbsp; the narrative I&#8217;ve accepted will flip\u2026&nbsp; from hearsay to testimony\u2026&nbsp; from conjecture to reality\u2026&nbsp; and almost like when you&#8217;ve had your cataracts removed\u2026&nbsp; from blurriness to clarity\u2026 And as I go through this transition\u2026&nbsp; I need to remain vigilant\u2026&nbsp; I need to remain open to what I can still&nbsp; learn\u2026&nbsp; to how I can still be formed\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; to what I can give to\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; and do for others\u2026&nbsp; because if I think I&#8217;m too busy getting ready to not be too busy at all\u2026&nbsp; I may miss out on opportunities that may come my way\u2026&nbsp; on something that will flip another narrative I&#8217;ve been telling myself\u2026&nbsp; and which also turns out to not be true\u2026 Professor Raj Nadella writes\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; a few years ago\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; I saw a cartoon\u2026&nbsp; in it\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; there&#8217;s a CEO\u2026&nbsp; a laborer\u2026&nbsp; and a foreigner\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; sitting at a table\u2026&nbsp; the CEO has a huge plate-full of cookies in front of him\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; the laborer has one cookie\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; and the immigrant has none\u2026&nbsp; and the CEO turns to the laborer and says\u2026&nbsp; Careful mate\u2026&nbsp; that foreigner wants your cookie!\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; it\u2019s a clear attempt to shift attention away from the CEO\u2019s hoarding\u2026&nbsp; and to create division\u2026&nbsp; and Empire continues to do that even now\u2026&nbsp; by asking questions like\u2026&nbsp; Who&#8217;s a real American\u2026&nbsp; and who deserves its benefits\u2026&nbsp; and it creates additional division by pitting marginalized communities against each other\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; so it&#8217;s that much harder to address this oppression\u2026 The first-century historian Josephus\u2026 &nbsp;describes the ongoing tension between Jews and the residents of Tyre\u2026&nbsp; these two colonized communities fought over several issues\u2026&nbsp; but primarily\u2026&nbsp; over the limited resources that were left\u2026&nbsp; after the Roman Empire siphoned off what it wanted\u2026&nbsp; and Rome deflected attention away from its selfish economic practices by convincing these oppressed communities\u2026 &nbsp;that they could survive\u2026&nbsp; only by eliminating the competition from the other oppressed groups\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; with whom they lived\u2026&nbsp; and this led to a mindset of scarcity among these communities\u2026 The Syrophoenician woman\u2026&nbsp; &nbsp;and the deaf man\u2026 &nbsp;were both people on the fringes\u2026&nbsp; like the foreigner at the table whose plate was empty\u2026&nbsp; but the woman spoke up\u2026&nbsp; out of desperation for her daughter\u2026&nbsp; and those who brought the deaf man to Jesus\u2026&nbsp; spoke up on his behalf\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and there&#8217;s no record of any dialogue between Jesus and these advocates\u2026&nbsp; he simply takes the deaf man aside and heals him\u2026 But today&#8217;s Gospel records the back and forth between Jesus and this woman\u2026&nbsp; and I wonder what we can learn from Jesus\u2019 reluctance to grant the Syrophoenician woman\u2019s request for a miracle\u2026&nbsp; was it fear that if the food\u2026&nbsp; in other words\u2026&nbsp; the benefits of this new Kingdom\u2026&nbsp; were to be extended to her community\u2026&nbsp; that the Jewish people would have less\u2026&nbsp; would lose out\u2026&nbsp; that it would be a zero-sum game\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; in which only one\u2026&nbsp; or the other can benefit\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; but not both\u2026 And at first\u2026&nbsp; this is just how Jesus reacts\u2026&nbsp; and it may possibly have been\u2026&nbsp; at least partly\u2026&nbsp; that he was simply exhausted\u2026&nbsp; that his inner resources were depleted because of the miracles and healings he&#8217;d been performing\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; after all&#8230;&nbsp; the text says\u2026&nbsp;&nbsp; that he didn&#8217;t want anyone to know he was there\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; but he spoke harshly to this woman\u2026&nbsp; saying\u2026&nbsp; it&#8217;s not fair to take the children\u2019s food and throw it to the dogs\u2026&nbsp; as though the Kingdom could somehow be depleted\u2026 Now The Jesus Seminar folk\u2026&nbsp; were a group of biblical scholars whose goal was to establish the authenticity of what Jesus actually said and did\u2026&nbsp; and they believe that Jesus must really have said this\u2026&nbsp; because it was kind of unflattering\u2026&nbsp; and it would have been so easy to leave it out of the bible\u2026&nbsp; but if it really could be attributed to him\u2026&nbsp; well\u2026&nbsp; you wouldn&#8217;t want to lose any of his actual words\u2026&nbsp; would you\u2026&nbsp; so we&#8217;d better leave it in\u2026&nbsp; ]&nbsp; and maybe\u2026&nbsp; taking the children\u2019s food and throwing it to the dogs\u2026&nbsp; maybe that was an expression that people knew\u2026&nbsp; which referred to someone who couldn&#8217;t appreciate what was being offered to them\u2026&nbsp; that it would be wasted on them\u2026&nbsp; kind of like casting pearls before swine\u2026 But the woman\u2019s insightful response affirms\u2026&nbsp; &nbsp;that even if her community gained access to the gifts of the kingdom\u2026&nbsp; Jesus&#8217; community would not be [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":2639,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_exactmetrics_skip_tracking":false,"_exactmetrics_sitenote_active":false,"_exactmetrics_sitenote_note":"","_exactmetrics_sitenote_category":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[5],"tags":[143,255],"class_list":["post-2638","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-sermons","tag-jesus-heals","tag-time-after-pentecost"],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/09\/p06vcfqjsmaller.jpg","jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2638","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=2638"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2638\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":2640,"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2638\/revisions\/2640"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/2639"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=2638"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=2638"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/twochurches.org\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=2638"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}